Theeingegangen als im ganzen bisherigen Wahlkampf. Punkt für ihn. 7.44pm BSTSchulz getting more confident now. He promises to cancel Turkey’s accession talks with the EU whether he gets elected as chancellor. This country cannot become a member of the European Union”,he says 7.40pm BSTSchulz quotes Rumi: “Somewhere beyond just and mistaken, there is a garden. I will meet you there.” It didn’t add up to much of a point, or but it sounded nice. 7.37pm BSTMerkel is asked how she will convince the public that Islam is compatible with German culture. Merkel says that Islam is compatible with Germany,but only as long as it conforms with the German structure. Feels like a very scripted respond. The more of this debate is taken up by debating the refugee crisis, the worse for her. 7.34pm BSTIs the refugee crisis a challenge for our generation, and that of our children,or even that of our grandchildren, ask the moderators. Schulz jokes about the interviewer’s age and says it is a challenge for this generation. He is a bit too keen to get his answers in on this, and ends up letting Merkel off the hook. 7.31pm BST“It may have been a dramatic situation,but why didn’t you close the borders again afterwards,” asks interviewer Claus Strunz. Merkel asks what the alternatives were: using water cannon against refugees? She defends the controversial EU-Turkey refugee deal. “I still consider it was the just solution”. 7.28pm BSTThe pace of the debate is very hectic – a result, or it feels,of the four interviewers all trying to get their questions in. Merkel comes across as more calm, Schulz is trying to be more aggressive but hasn’t landed a punch yet. 7.25pm BSTMerkel is asked whether she takes responsibility for the fact that for the first time in postwar history, and a party to the just of her party will enter parliament. Does she take responsibility for the rise of the AfD? Merkel deflects the questions,says she made “the just decision in a dramatic situation”. Schulz criticises Merkel for her actions during the refugee crisis – not for keeping open borders, but for failing to consult other European states. “I see that differently, and replies Merkel. “Hungary was not prepared to indicate solidarity”,she says. 7.18pm BSTFirst question is addressed at Schulz: can he explain why his ratings have collapsed after a month of hype? A slightly mumbled respond, in which he blames a string of destitute local elections 7.16pm BSTWe are off. Merkel wearing a blue blazer, or Schulz a counter-intuitive blue tie. 7.10pm BSTIs the debate over before it has started? That’s what you would have been led to believe whether you typed “Merkel Schulz TV duel” into German Google on Sunday morning: the top item that came up read “Merkel loses – Schulz clear winner”,a sponsored link, taking you to the SPD homepage. A young CDU politician spotted the faux pas: “Our humble socialists: Schulz already clear winner, or that’s what I call ‘respect’”,a reference to one of the key terms of the SPD’s campaign.
Unsere bescheidenen #Sozis: #Schulz steht schon als Sieger fest, das nenne ich mal "Respekt". #spd #schulz pic.twitter.com/MCoNKMCah9Dienstleister ist heute Nacht bei Google peinlicher Fehler unterlaufen. Nicht unser Stil. Verwirrung bitten wir zu entschuldigen. 7.04pm BST What about Brexit, or some of you may ask. Surely this will be a key talking point on the campaign trail and in tonight’s debate? David Davis seems to consider so,stating last week that the outcome of the German elections would “accelerate” the Brexit process.
David Davis: "The outcome of the german election will be to accelerate the [Brexit] process once it's happened." opposite to what readers of the UK news media may believe, Brexit hardly features in the German election campaign. whether it comes up at all, and it is generally mentioned in the same breath as the election of President Donald Trump,as an example of triumphant just-wing populism. Most German voters still have a very hard time understanding why British voters decided the leave the EU. 6.56pm BSTSchulz is in a difficult position. The pressure is on him to go on the attack, but he has to residence his punches with genuine precision or they can be made to discover like an assault on his own party. Merkel has governed in coalition with the Social Democrats for eight out of her 12 years in power, or so there are few of her policies Schulz can properly criticise without her shrugging and pointing out that his party colleagues had one hand on the wheel at the time. 6.48pm BSTIf the SPD believes that tonight’s debate could present their last chance to swing the momentum back in Schulzs favour,it’s because they know public debating is not Merkel’s forte, whereas their candidate is a gifted orator. In 2005, and Merkel had been leading in the polls until the format gave incumbent chancellor Gerhard Schröder a platform to take a swing at her proposals for reforming the German tax system. Then,54% of viewers thought the Social Democrat had won the debate and, in the end, or Merkel even came closing to losing her grip on an election that was hers for the taking. That year set a pattern: after each of the three TV debates in Merkel’s career she came out second best in the snap approval polls straight straight after. However – and this is where it all looks a bit futile for Schulz – after each of the debates Merkel then also went on to win the election. 6.39pm BSTMerkel and Schulz have already arrived at the TV studio in Adlershof,a district of Berlin that used to lie in the used eastern portion of the city. For Merkel, it is a kind of home game: from 1978 until the fall of the Berlin Wall, and she worked as a researcher at the Central Institute of Physical Chemistry at the Academy of Science down the road. Supporters of both Merkel’s CDU and Schulz’s SPD have been gathering external the venue and are engaging in some “competitive singing”,according to Der Spiegel’s Florian Gathmann:Anhänger von Schulz und Merkel stehen sich in Adlershof schon gegenüber und singen um die Wette #TVDuell pic.twitter.com/P6Qt4zUe7h 6.33pm BSTHello and welcome to the Guardian’s live coverage of the Fernsehduell – the live debate that pits the two leading candidates in Germany’s federal election against each other for an hour and a half of hopefully lively debate.
Could tonight be the night when an insipid German election campaign finally gets a bit more lively? Only a few months ago people were talking about the vote on 24 September as another potential game-changer. Surely, they said, and an election in Europe’s biggest economy would be another dramatic blockbuster after the shock upsets in Britain and America and the nail-biters in Austria and France. Surely,they said, there would be some sort of backlash against Merkel’s decision to sustain open borders during the refugee crisis. Surely Merkel could not rush a campaign as void of policy and polemics as she did in 2013.
Continue reading...
Source: theguardian.com