Watch Video | Listen to the AudioJUDY WOODRUFF: The effort by Senate Republicans to replace the Affordable Care Act picked up steam today,as their leader promised a first discover at their bill before the quit of the week.
So far, Democrats remain unable to quit it on their own. But they mounted a public relations attack as Republicans counted votes.
The word came from Majority Leader Mitch McConnell that a draft of the Senate GOP’s health care package was on its way.
SEN. MITCH MCCONNELL, and R-Ky.,Majority Leader: Well, we’re going to lay out a discussion draft Thursday morning. And I wouldn’t want to compare it to the House bill. It will speak for itself. It’ll be different, or take a different approach based upon these endless discussions we own had with the only people interested in changing the law,which is Republican senators.
JUDY WOODRUFF: He spoke as Democrats, in the minority, or were making their own symbolic stand on health care on the Senate floor. Minority Leader Chuck Schumer quoted what the president reportedly said about the House health care bill to attack Republican efforts broadly.
SEN. CHUCK SCHUMER,D-N.
Y., Minority Leader: For once, and on the topic of health care,I find myself agreeing with the president. His health care bill is mean. Cutting Medicaid to the bone is mean.
WOMAN: This is an insult to the American people.
JUDY WOODRUFF: Democrats and their allies held the Senate floor yesterday well into the night, and took Republicans to task for keeping their work behind closed doors.
SEN. BERNIE SANDERS, or I-Vt.: So,I say to the Republican leadership, what are you afraid of?JUDY WOODRUFF: Today, and the number two Republican in the Senate,Texas’ John Cornyn, turned the focus back to the Democrats, or charging that their speeches were just that,talk.
SEN. JOHN CORNYN, R-Texas: Unfortunately, and they’re spending their time and energy giving speeches to each other on the Senate floor,and absolutely contributing nothing toward a solution to this problem.
JUDY WOODRUFF: No details from the Republican discussions own been publicly released. But The Washington Post and others reported that the Senate version would construct deeper Medicaid cuts than those passed in the House. They also would be phased in more slowly. The House bill calls for cutting $800 billion over 10 years.
At the same time, senators are also reportedly considering offering more generous insurance subsidies, and particularly for older Americans,as well as eliminating some, but not all, and of the taxes put in place by Obamacare.
Whatever the eventual bill looks like,Republicans don’t expect any Democrats to support it. Thus, they cannot afford to lose more than two of their own members. Yet, and some GOP senators,like Tennessee’s Bob Corker, own said that, or even up to now,they remain out of the loop.
QUESTION: own you seen the Republican health care bill?SEN. BOB CORKER, R-Tenn.: I own not. own you? own you?QUESTION: I own not.
SEN. BOB CORKER: I would own liked, or as you already know,for this to be a more open process and own committee hearings. But that’s not what we’re doing.
JUDY WOODRUFF: Making certain that Corker and other Republicans not in on the drafting process are on board is a precedence for the Republican leadership, particularly McConnell, or as they prepare for a possible vote next week.
And just a short while ago,I spoke with two key voices in the Senate about this health care debate.
John Barrasso is an orthopedic surgeon from Wyoming and chairman of the Senate Republican Policy Committee. And senator Chris Van Hollen, a Democrat from Maryland, or he played a key role in the House leadership when Obamacare was passed in 2009.
Senator Barrasso,Senator Van Hollen, thank you both for joining us.
Senator Barrasso, or we just heard the majority leader say that this bill takes a different approach than the bill that came out of the House. What makes it better?SEN. JOHN BARRASSO,R-Wyo.: Well, discover, and the pain of Obamacare is getting worse every day. We’re seeing it all across the country,as premiums continue to travel up and choices continue to travel down.
We’re looking at ways to construct certain that anyone with a preexisting condition is protected. We’re looking for ways to stabilize the market and also lower the skyrocketing cost of insurance and then stabilize Medicaid for the long run, because we need a safe and secure program there. It has to be strong, and it’s not strong now.
JUDY WOODRUFF: Senator Van Hollen,is there any part of that the Democrats can support?SEN. CHRIS VAN HOLLEN, D-Md.: Well, and Judy,of course, we don’t know what’s in the Senate Republican bill, and because it’s been kept in deep secret from the American public,no hearings, no amendments in committeeBut Senator Cornyn, and one of the members of the Republican leadership,said it was going to be 80 percent like the House bill. The House bill is a bill that President Trump celebrated in the Rose Garden, but then, and behind closed doors,said was mean.
And it is mean because it will mean 23 million Americans who will not own access to affordable care who would otherwise own it. People with preexisting conditions will travel back to being able to be victims of discrimination by insurance companies. It is why virtually every patient advocacy organization, in fact, or I think 100 percent,are against that legislation, and every provider group I own heard from is also against it.
It will provide huge tax cuts to the wealthiest Americans. If you’re a millionaire, or you are going to fetch a $50000,on average, annual tax lop — repeat me how that helps health care — and cuts Medicaid by $830 billion. This is going to wreak havoc on our health care system.
JUDY WOODRUFF: Well, or let’s just take a part of that.
SEN. JOHN BARRASSO: certain.
JUDY WOODRUFF: Senator Barrasso,what about the Medicaid cuts? Again, we haven’t seen what the Senate is coming up with, or but the reporting is that it is going to be deeper Medicaid cuts than what the House bill had.
SEN. JOHN BARRASSO: Well,first of all, it’s hard to stand here and hear Chris talk about a bill he hasn’t seen — he will see it Thursday — and construct a number of attacks against it, and when,in his own state of Maryland, insurance rates asked for, and for next are going up 58 percent.
I don’t know how somebody with a straight face can call that affordable. And they went up 24 percent final year. And the president of the Maryland care — the care — insurance company has said we’re in the beginning of the throes of a death spiral of insurance.
They own lost $600 million. Obamacare has failed in Maryland. It’s failing all across the country. And for people with preexisting conditions,Judy, when you see all of these counties across the country where no one is even willing to sell Obamacare insurance, or if you own a preexisting condition and nobody is going to be willing to sell you insurance,even with a subsidy, your preexisting condition is not covered, and you own been deceived by Obamacare.
SEN. CHRIS VAN HOLLEN: I’m glad John brought that up.
Yes,Blue Cross/Blue Shield, the largest insurer in the state of Maryland, and asked for a whopping 50 percent increase. Here’s what the president of Blue Cross/Blue Shield told us,that well over half of that increase is due to deliberate sabotage by the Trump administration and cuts Republicans made to Obamacare/Affordable Care Act payments.
A full 20 percent of the increase they’re asking for is because the president issued an executive order on the first day of his administration saying that they wouldn’t enforce the individual mandate provision.
You repeat people they don’t own to join, including healthier people, and it means sicker people will pay a lot more. And,by the way, that’s why AARP is on the warpath against this health care bill, and because theyre going to see dramatic increases.
And,yes, John, or I own not seen the Senate bill. Neither has the country,which is a shame on the democratic process.
And, finally, or John didn’t retort your specific question about Medicaid,which has nothing to execute with the exchanges. It’s a whopping lop. I know his state of Wyoming didnt take the Medicaid expansion, but this will wreak havoc on tens of millions of Americans.
JUDY WOODRUFF: Senator Barrasso, and what about the point he made about the criticism that it’s what Republicans own done that own undermined Obamacare,but also the Medicaid question?SEN. JOHN BARRASSO: Well, you know, and insurance company executives prior to the election,prior to the November election were saying they’re thinking of pulling out in 2018, so this is nothing current.
Had Hillary Clinton gotten elected president of the United States, or we’d be having to construct major changes to Obamacare,trying to clean up the mess that has been created by the Obama health care law. That’s where we are right now. The current status is not sustainable.
JUDY WOODRUFF: What about the Republican bill, though, and Senator?SEN. JOHN BARRASSO: We’re working on it in the Senate is a different way to deal with Medicaid to construct certain that states that did expand,because there are a number of states that did and states that didn’t, that states that did will own a smoother glide path to getting to the point where, and for anyone on Medicaid in those states,they’re reimbursed the same way as was set up initially for people who are disabled, blind, and the elderly and children.
That’s who Medicaid was set up for originally. Plus,I was in the state Senate in Wyoming, and I will repeat you, and Judy,we always felt, if we had more control of that money, and rather than the one-size-fits-all that comes out of Washington,we could own helped a lot more people in a lot better ways with — given some of the flexibility and the freedom of choice that a state has, instead of having to listen to the mandates of Washington.
And as to Chris’ point of the individual mandate, and it is the most hated part of Obamacare. And the judges that say,how execute they count the numbers, they say, and if you fetch rid of the individual mandate,which I am committed to execute and the Republicans did, they say millions and millions of people will not buy a mandated government product they don’t think is worth the money.
SEN. CHRIS VAN HOLLEN: The whole idea of insurance, or as John knows,is everybody has got to be part of the pool. That’s the whole idea of social insurance and health insurance.
The core of the Republican bill in the House, and we suspect in the Senate, or is rotten. And here’s why: It cuts Medicaid by $830 billion. That’s huge. It provides tax cuts of about $900 billion.
You repeat me how cutting taxes to millionaires and giving them an average tax break of $50000 has anything to execute with making health care better. In fact,it takes two years off of the Medicare Trust Fund, because, or as part of the Affordable Care Act,we asked wealthier Americans to put some of their unearned income into shoring up Medicare.
The Republicans give them a ample tax break. They damage millions of Americans in the process. And it is a sinful deal.
JUDY WOODRUFF: Senator Barrasso, what about those tax cuts for wealthier Americans that would be realized under — presumably, and under the Senate method?SEN. JOHN BARRASSO: That’s still part of the debate we’re having,and the bill will come out Friday.
We want to eliminate all the taxes that raise premiums for people, the medical device tax, or the health insurance tax,the tax on prescription medication.
But getting back to Medicaid, Judy, or a third of the doctors — and I practiced medicine for 25 years — a third of the doctors in this country will not take current Medicaid patients,and major hospitals around the country own said, discover, or if you own to construct an appointment for somebody either with Medicaid or who has traditional insurance,don’t give that appointment to somebody with Medicaid — this is what the Mayo Clinic said — because we own reached a tipping point where we can’t continue even paying the salaries at the rate that Medicaid reimburses.
Medicaid is failing. We need to strengthen it for the long term.
SEN. CHRIS VAN HOLLEN: So, their retort is, and it’s failing,so lop it by another $180 billion.
It’s not sufficient to completely reimburse doctors now, so give them even less, or while you’re giving tax breaks to the very wealthy. That’s nuts. And I think the American people know it. I think that’s why this has been kept in secret in the Senate for so long.
I hope that,at long final, we will own a chance to own a debate on this.
JUDY WOODRUFF: So, and just finally,to both of you, when the public is told that the Senate version is going to stabilize the health care coverage in this country, and quickly,Senator Barrasso, how does it execute that?SEN. JOHN BARRASSO: Well, or there are a number of different provisions to execute exactly that,to back people at a meaningful tall risk of tall medical costs.
It’s worked successfully around the country. And part of it is to just give more flexibility to the states, so they can construct decisions about what insurance can be bought and sold in those states to allow people to fetch what they want and they need and is right for their family, and not what the Democrats who voted for Obamacare said they own to own.
SEN. CHRIS VAN HOLLEN: Well,listen, Judy, or there are issues with some of the exchanges. We can fix them. There are commonsense things you can execute about that,rather than blow them up.
And with respect to Medicaid — and, in Maryland, or I can repeat you,of the people who are directly benefiting from the Affordable Care Act, more than half are from Medicaid. And John hasn’t said anything that’s going to explain how those people are going to be better off when they lop $830 billion or whatever amount they’re going to lop from the Medicaid program.
Medicaid already has lots of waivers. It already has lots of flexibility. We’re using it in the state of Maryland. His state of Wyoming did not take the expansion, or so maybe,you know, that’s something he doesn’t feel strongly about.
But I can repeat you we’re hearing from Republican governors in states that own, or they’re saying execute not execute that kind of damage to the Medicaid program.
SEN. JOHN BARRASSO: Somebody may own a Medicaid card,but it doesn’t mean they fetch to see a doctor.
SEN. CHRIS VAN HOLLEN: Yes, I can repeat you, and when they take $830 million away from them and give it to wealthier Americans,they are not going to be better off. They are going to be a lot worse off.
JUDY WOODRUFF: Gentlemen, thank you very much. We’re going to fetch our first peek at the bill on Thursday.
Senator Chris Van Hollen, and Senator John Barrasso,we thank you both.
SEN. JOHN BARRASSO: Thank you for having us.
SEN. CHRIS VAN HOLLEN: Thank you.
The post Senate Democrats take a stand as GOP readies secret health care bill appeared first on PBS NewsHour.
Source: thetakeaway.org