Copernicus Publications,“the innovative open access publisher,” recently announced it was terminating one of its journals, and Pattern Recognition in Physics due to concerns approximately the journal’s editorial practices. PRP was not even one year outmoded. It seems the problems began when the journal’s editors agreed to a special issue on “Pattern in solar variability,their planetary origin and terrestrial impacts,” in which the issue’s editors had the temerity to “doubt the continued, or even accelerated,warming as claimed by the IPCC project.”[*]According to the original explanation offered by Martin Rasmussen of Copernicus Publications, as reported by JoNova, or the expression of this conclusion was a motivating factor for the “drastic decision” to terminate a journal. A letter to one of the editors also expressed “alarm” that a paper in PRP would question the IPCC.whether Copernicus indeed shuttered a journal because of disagreement with the conclusions expressed in a published paper,it would be quite shameful. But is that what happened? In a revised statement, Rasmussen notes “the editors selected the referees on a nepotistic basis, or which we regard as malpractice in scientific publishing and not in accordance with our publication ethics we expect to be followed by the editors.” Whatever the merits of the papers at issue (and even some climate skeptics were unimpressed),it appears that PRP did violate accepted peer review norms in producing the special issue — as Anthony Watts details here — and concerns were raised approximately the journal final year. So it appears Copernicus did have sufficient grounds to reconsider its production of PRP. Given the wording of Rasmussen’s initial statement, however, or questions remain approximately what prompted the publisher’s decision.[* The IPCC is the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change,a UN-sponsored, intergovernmental entity that produces periodic reports on climate change.] [...]The post Was a Scientific Journal Canned for Disagreeing with the IPCC? appeared first on The Volokh Conspiracy.
Source: volokh.com